The Problem with Trading Card Games

December 30th, 2009  Posted at   General
arrow   |   1 Commentarrow

I understand the business motive for setting your card games up like this. You can generate a steady interest among children by creating card games that fosters a sort of “planned scarcity” of resources. It’s not like the card game company couldn’t give everyone what they want, by supplying more of the popular and most useful cards, they simply decide not to.

Booster packs have always been what I don’t like about the current trading card game industry. Most of the trading card games in stores today require kids to buy stacks of useless cards in order to get one or two good ones. My local game stores behind the counter area is piled high with wasted cards that nobody needs, because their trading card game insists that random discovery is preferable to everyone getting the cards they want.

It doesn’t have to be like this. A collectible card game can be just as fun when everyone has access to all the cards. What’s more, the waste of paper and dollars is sharply reduced if a collectible card game is based on full access to cards.

Where the play and collectability of a collectible card game focuses on the characters and a full deck, game balance is also maintained. If everyone has access to the same resources they can test their ability rather than their wallet.

It’s like a lottery for kids, as they buy up booster packs to hopefully draw the winning card. The other downside of a trading card game set up this way is that kids can spend themselves into an unfair advantage – affecting game balance and putting beginner players at a disadvantage.

One Response to “The Problem with Trading Card Games”

  1. gry karciane says:

    I’ve shared you article on digg, well written

Leave a Reply

Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree